Rolling Stone pisses me off. I was perusing Wikipedia for Weezer album reviews (this is what I do), and I noticed a link for Rolling Stone’s review, where it awarded the album 5 stars. This did not sparkle with me, as I distinctly recall the review being much lower at the time of publication. The review link on Wikipedia led to an article written in 2004. Pinkerton being an album released in 1996, this clearly was not the original review. I had to Google a little bit before finding the 1996 review, which gave the album 3 stars instead of 5. This isn’t the first time I’ve seen this from RS. They’ve been covering their tracks for many an issue now, ever since they forgot how to measure hipness.
Very rarely do you ever see a 5 star album review in RS. They usually only come in small bursts, and almost always when it concerns an old rocker(s) who just can not rock like they used to. Cases in point: Check out the Rolling Stone reviews to both Springsteen and U2’s new albums. If you too have listened to these records, you might be as confused as I (because they suck, pretty much, all save a song or two). Sure, everything is relative to the critic, blah blah blah, but can you find one song, other than the theme to “The Wrestler” on Springsteen’s new one that you could consider a classic? It’s the longest EP you’ll ever hear. Worse off: The Wrestler’s theme is a bonus track.
Why is this? Why is Rolling Stone so ill-defined in review structure? Why must they put all their faith in hype magnets? Why does Kanye garner one of the only five star reviews by a young artist? Why was that four years ago?
I like to think of Victoria Jackson’s old movie review system from Saturday Night Live:
4 Stars: Pretty Good
3 Stars: The Best
2 Stars: The Worst
1 Star: Pretty Good Too
Of course, no journalist wants to be wrong, ever. This is the 3 ½ star rule. If you’re absolutely sure that a particular album is a bonafide classic, the best album by the artist to date, the zeitgeist-like statement that defines an entire generation that will be remembered forever in the history books: 3 ½ out of 5 stars. Because we could have had it so much better, and sure, it just hasn’t had the time to prove itself. Here’s the excuse: We didn’t see what kind of timely influence the record would have on music, there’s no reason to reward it as such. Forget that Pinkerton was so instantly and infinitely poptastic from the first time you heard it. What’s important is that many emo bands used it as an influence. Yes, we actually praise the roots of emo, apparently. Hell, I like it, and I was an emo kid, right? So fuck it. Rolling Stone just might be objective after all. They see a movement for a movement’s sake, and that’s the bottom line.
But it still doesn’t solve the conundrum of ratings in relation to quality. Kanye had five stars, and only on his second album. Rolling Stone’s review came out well after every other beat rag had praised the shit out of “Late Registration,” so it might not be the best example. That’s a funny part of RS: They are the single most influential score in the reviews scene, yet they seem completely reliant on the reviews of other sources. When tested to their limits, when they must prove themselves without aid, when they must review a classic and spectacular record before any other source beats them to the punch: 3 ½ stars. It’s like a B+ for teachers.
For any fans out there, consider the plight of Animal Collective’s “Merriweather Post Pavillion.” If you follow the current trends of popular music, you might know that this is a strong contender for the best album of the decade. AC is infinitely influential to most every band on the popular indie scene, and MPP is an absolute pop marvel of the highest caliber. I bet you can guess the score from Rolling Stone.
Why does it matter? RS hasn’t been a real measure of quality for decades, so it needn’t be relied upon anymore, not since almost every other media outlet is hella online-capable. Even some of the databases have their own rating systems. Allmusic chronicles almost every record ever made, and then it slaps on a star review. Merriweather Post Pavillion fares a little better here, at 4 ½ stars, just short of 5 star perfection. And that’s great, I’m not asking for everyone to unanimously praise this thing. It took me a while to get used to. I even appreciate seeing some bad reviews here and there. At least people are being true to their gut. But here’s the rub: Allmusic’s score for Asia’s 1982 self-titled debut album: 5 Stars.
Very rarely do you ever see a 5 star album review in RS. They usually only come in small bursts, and almost always when it concerns an old rocker(s) who just can not rock like they used to. Cases in point: Check out the Rolling Stone reviews to both Springsteen and U2’s new albums. If you too have listened to these records, you might be as confused as I (because they suck, pretty much, all save a song or two). Sure, everything is relative to the critic, blah blah blah, but can you find one song, other than the theme to “The Wrestler” on Springsteen’s new one that you could consider a classic? It’s the longest EP you’ll ever hear. Worse off: The Wrestler’s theme is a bonus track.
Why is this? Why is Rolling Stone so ill-defined in review structure? Why must they put all their faith in hype magnets? Why does Kanye garner one of the only five star reviews by a young artist? Why was that four years ago?
I like to think of Victoria Jackson’s old movie review system from Saturday Night Live:
4 Stars: Pretty Good
3 Stars: The Best
2 Stars: The Worst
1 Star: Pretty Good Too
Of course, no journalist wants to be wrong, ever. This is the 3 ½ star rule. If you’re absolutely sure that a particular album is a bonafide classic, the best album by the artist to date, the zeitgeist-like statement that defines an entire generation that will be remembered forever in the history books: 3 ½ out of 5 stars. Because we could have had it so much better, and sure, it just hasn’t had the time to prove itself. Here’s the excuse: We didn’t see what kind of timely influence the record would have on music, there’s no reason to reward it as such. Forget that Pinkerton was so instantly and infinitely poptastic from the first time you heard it. What’s important is that many emo bands used it as an influence. Yes, we actually praise the roots of emo, apparently. Hell, I like it, and I was an emo kid, right? So fuck it. Rolling Stone just might be objective after all. They see a movement for a movement’s sake, and that’s the bottom line.
But it still doesn’t solve the conundrum of ratings in relation to quality. Kanye had five stars, and only on his second album. Rolling Stone’s review came out well after every other beat rag had praised the shit out of “Late Registration,” so it might not be the best example. That’s a funny part of RS: They are the single most influential score in the reviews scene, yet they seem completely reliant on the reviews of other sources. When tested to their limits, when they must prove themselves without aid, when they must review a classic and spectacular record before any other source beats them to the punch: 3 ½ stars. It’s like a B+ for teachers.
For any fans out there, consider the plight of Animal Collective’s “Merriweather Post Pavillion.” If you follow the current trends of popular music, you might know that this is a strong contender for the best album of the decade. AC is infinitely influential to most every band on the popular indie scene, and MPP is an absolute pop marvel of the highest caliber. I bet you can guess the score from Rolling Stone.
Why does it matter? RS hasn’t been a real measure of quality for decades, so it needn’t be relied upon anymore, not since almost every other media outlet is hella online-capable. Even some of the databases have their own rating systems. Allmusic chronicles almost every record ever made, and then it slaps on a star review. Merriweather Post Pavillion fares a little better here, at 4 ½ stars, just short of 5 star perfection. And that’s great, I’m not asking for everyone to unanimously praise this thing. It took me a while to get used to. I even appreciate seeing some bad reviews here and there. At least people are being true to their gut. But here’s the rub: Allmusic’s score for Asia’s 1982 self-titled debut album: 5 Stars.
Have you heard 1982’s Asia? It’s the worst fucking record in musical history. 5 stars. Allmusic didn’t exist in 1982, so they hail the shit for proving it can sell. That’s despicable. I mean, shit, Asia? Really? Asia? Allmusic loses for the same spirit.
Pitchfork is only half-guilty. They will not score anything new with a perfect rating for fear of any similarities to certain UK-based reviews publications, but they do honour generously, rip apart appropriately (read their review for Weezer’s “Make Believe”), and dip into their back catalogue. While the first two Wire albums are perfect tens in my books, why not slap the rating on a perfect ten from today? It could be better, I guess. Perhaps only time will tell? Again? Like the other ones? Like Asia?
Honestly, the only person I see following their gut on any review is the craziest fucker out there: Roger Ebert. It’s perfect. The guy used to rip apart everything, almost died, gained a newfound respect for life, and now treats every film as some sort of freak revelation. There is no end to his 4 star madness. The only really noticeable exception is “The Bucket List,” which temporarily reminded him of his near-death experience, and prompted a trash review as a result. But really, I have so much respect for a guy who gave “Across the Universe” such a kickass score. It’s not a perfect film, and most people hate it, but Ebert, ever the punked out motherfucker, gives it a perfect score because it made him temporarily happy. We need more stupid people reviewing this crap. We need the people interviewed outside of the theatre for “Beverly Hills Chihuahua” in Atlanta to write some of their choice ratings down on paper (eg. “It was awesome!” the end). They have no pride in the first place, so they can afford to be wrong. And who knows, 20 years from now, “Beverly Hills Chihuahua” may be as fondly regarded as “The Shawshank Redemption,” and Papa Roach’s new record could have been the one that changed it all.
No comments:
Post a Comment